the unlikely story of how America slipped the surly bonds of earth & came to believe in signs & portents that would make the middle ages blush

via PayPal...

via Amazon...

this site is a labor of love. i.e., if you love me enough, I'll be able to complete it. send proof of love via buttons above. please. if you can. thanks.







(not obsolete yet)

Google Book Search

July 2005
August 2005
September 2005
October 2005
November 2005
December 2005
January 2006
February 2006
March 2006
April 2006
May 2006
June 2006
July 2006
August 2006
September 2006
October 2006
November 2006
December 2006
January 2007
February 2007
March 2007
April 2007
May 2007
June 2007
August 2007
September 2007
October 2007
November 2007
January 2008
February 2008
March 2008
April 2008
May 2008
June 2008
July 2008
August 2008
September 2008
October 2008
November 2008
December 2008
January 2009
February 2009
March 2009
April 2009
May 2009
November 2009
May 2010
March 2014

Francesco Armando
Tim Boucher
Marc Canter
Michael "OC" Clarke
Hernani Dimantas
Dream's End
Cory Doctorow
Esther Dyson
John Gehl
Dan Gillmor
Mike Golby
Annie Gottlieb
Howard Greenstein
Denise Howell
Joi Ito
Norm Jensen
Hylton Jolliffe
Dean Landsman
Steve Larsen
Madame Levy
wood s lot
Kevin Marks
Massimo Moruzzi
Tom Matrullo
Brian Millar
Eric Norlin
Rev Sam Norton
Frank Paynter
Chris Pirillo
Shelley Powers
JP Rangaswami
Paul Scheele
Connie Schmidt
Doc Searls
Euan Semple
George Sessum
Jeneane Sessum
Halley Suitt
Gaspar Torriero
Gary Turner
The Happy Tutor
Beat Waydown
David Weinberger
Donna Wentworth
Don Williams
Evan Williams
Xanadu Xero

another (maybe easier) way to read the back issues



mystic bourgeoisie 

Powered by Blogger



Enter Book Title or ISBN

New & Used Books - Find the Lowest Price - Compare more than a hundred book stores, 60,000 sellers, in a click.

Locations of visitors to this page

Blind Boy Apollo
and the All-White Astronauts

New Age "Asiatic" thought ... is establishing itself as the
hegemonic ideology of global capitalism. (Zizek)

Tuesday, April 11

meta: research tips & tricks

I've been meaning to write this one for quite a while now, so here goes. It has to do with the amazing tools available online for scholarly research. For instance, try this search for "occult revival" on Google Books. Do you have any idea how long a search like that used to take when the only tools were paper-based card catalogs in physical libraries? Not to knock libraries, but the answer could be literally: a lifetime.

Note that "occult revival" is not just some random pairing of words. The phrase is a term of art in studies of 19th century intellectual history. I didn't know this a year ago -- even though I'd probably come across the phrase many times in my reading. The way I learned this what you might call "specialized language" was through some really dumb software on Amazon that looks for what the company calls SIPs: statistically improbable phrases.

I should explain that by "really dumb," I don't mean bad. SIPs are incredibly useful. As I said, they're how I learned that "occult revival" was a phrase in common use among certain scholars -- and critically, that those scholars had written books I would very likely want to read. What I mean by dumb is that the software doesn't know squat about occultism, revived or otherwise, or anything whatsoever about the 19th century.

The first clue to how SIPs work lies in the word "statistically." We're not talking some sort of AI here (not, at any rate, the sort that used to make insupportable claims to "natural language understanding"). Instead, these are mindless number crunching algorithms, and in this case the "numbers" they crunch are digital representations of words. What they look for is something computational linguists call co-occurrence.

The second clue lies in the fact that certain words co-occur all the time. Think of clichés. Here's a handful grabbed off a page cleverly titled Clichés: Avoid Them Like The Plague.

  • ballpark figure
  • calm before the storm
  • dead as a doornail
  • fear and loathing [thanks Hunter!]
  • it was a dark and stormy night [thanks Bulwer!]

Clichés are statistically probable phrases. Which is why they don't convey much. I'll spare you a long digression here on the information theory of entropy, but trust me, it's germane. Now, if you had some way to do it -- say a huge corpus of text data and a super-slick co-occurrence algorithm or two -- you could identify such nearly meaningless phrases "simply" by tallying how many times they... um... occurred. And here's the dumb-but-good part: you could do this without needing clue one about meaning.

Happily for us, giant text corpuses and slick search algorithms are just the sorts of things that companies like Google and Amazon happen to have lying about. And if you can identify clichés, you can also identify non-clichés -- call them Statistically Improbable Phrases.

As it turns out, the phrase "occult revival" doesn't occur anywhere near as frequently as, say, "Hot enough for you?" or "Have a nice day!" But it does occur. And it recurs in certain types of books -- often enough to be statistically significant. In fact, this recurrence defines, in some dimension, what this class of books is "about." More precisely, the algorithm creates that class on the fly. And when you see a part of that class laid out, as below, a lightbulb can go off. It did for me.

This is called -- get ready for a rare technical term here -- learning.

No, not machine learning. Human learning. As in, you come away from the experience with more understanding than you had going in. And as I said at the start of this, it could take a lifetime to acquire this sort of knowledge using pre-digital research methods. Yeah, yeah, maybe that sort of hard work would make us more deeply knowledgeable, but look: some of us are born amateurs and dilettantes (see my discussion in Gonzo Marketing: Winning Through Worst Practices) and we don't have enough lifetimes to waste getting PhDs in all the specialized areas we might want to know something about. Do we? No, we do not. And besides, universities cost too damn much and they're full of arrogant motherjumpers who think they know it all, when the truth is, very damn few know even half of it.

Uh... please to forgive the little rant there. Call it my postmodern manifesto. But perhaps this has all been a bit too abstract. Here, let's have an example. I yanked the following off Amazon and tinkered a bit with the URLs, all of which now should work (they do in my browser, anyway; got Firefox?). Be sure to experiment a bit with the extra cool pull-down references (right after the little arrowheads).

    "occult revival" appears in these books:
    Learn more about Statistically Improbable Phrases (SIPs)

    20 references in Gurdjieff; The Key Concepts (Routledge Key Guides) by S. WELLBELOVED
    14 references in The New Encyclopedia of the Occult by John Michael Greer
    14 references in Spirituality and the Occult; From the Renaissance to the Modern by B.J. GIBBONS
    13 references in Occult Underground by James Webb
    12 references in Surrealism and the Sacred: Power, Eros, and the Occult in Modern Art by Celia Rabinovitch
    10 references in The Place of Enchantment : British Occultism and the Culture of the Modern by Alex Owen
    7 references in A Dark Muse : A History of the Occult by Gary Lachman
    6 references in Surrealism and the Occult : Shamanism, Magic, Alchemy, and the Birth of an Artistic Movement by Nadia Choucha
    6 references in Occultism, Witchcraft, and Cultural Fashions : Essays in Comparative Religion by Mircea Eliade
    6 references in Essential Golden Dawn by Chic & Sandra Tabatha Cicero
    6 references in Belief Beyond Boundaries: Wicca, Celtic Spirituality and the New Age (Religion Today-Tradition, Modernity & Change) by Joanne Pearson (Editor)
    5 references in Blast Your Way to Megabuck$ With My Secret Sex-Power Formula by Ramsey Dukes
    4 references in Helena Blavatsky (Western Esoteric Masters Series) by Helena Blavatsky, Nicholas Goodrick-Clarke (Introduction)
    1 reference in The Occult by Colin Wilson
    1 reference in Modernism and the Celtic Revival by Gregory Castle
    1 reference in The Magus: A Complete System of Occult Philosophy by Francis Barrett

    Search for "occult revival"

Before publishers start having heart attacks -- "look at all our stuff this guy is stealing!" -- let me hasten to say that, of the above list, I purchased all the titles you see pictured in the right column (I managed to resist Blast Your Way to Megabuck$ With My Secret Sex-Power Formula). And I purchased them, in many cases, because this search pulled them up.

Finally, this is why I buy from Amazon. I learn there. And I learn there in a way I never could at a walk-in Barnes & Noble store -- or even on their site. As to all the poor Mom & Pop bookstores Amazon has supposedly disenfranchised, give me a break. Amazon has given these stores (any of them that wants it) a global market reach they never could have developed on their own. My only gripe is that this has created a virtual market for used books, the prices of which, as a result, are floating -- some soaring -- ever higher. Bad news for me. Great news for Mom and Pop. And of course, for Jeff Bezos -- to whose laudable vision and maniacal anonymous coding teams this piece is gratefully dedicated. Even at today's <koff> elevated prices, Amazon is still way cheaper than a couple Ivy League sheepskins.

  • NOTE: Amazon did not supply any of of the views expressed above. They are my own. Neither did they pay me anything for writing this. However, I'd like to take this opportunity to point out that it's never too late. Amazon gift certificates made out to always gladly accepted. <g>